The bottom line is that although growth is slowing in MZM which is our preferred broad liquidity indicator, there is no indication that money supply growth is cntracting (e.g.negative).
Theories abound. We like to look at the data.
There are various interpretations and we look into almost all of them.
But we like to keep an eye on the data, and skip arguments that are long on rhetorical flourishes and short of hard analysis.
A monetary deflation is possible. A price deflation in response to slack aggregate demand is not only possible it is happening. We are in a recession. Demand is decreasing. And money supply growth should be decreasing in sympathy with that.
We could even tell you how to cause a monetary deflation, and are confident we could do it. Raising short term interest rates to 20 percent would probably do the trick pretty handily. Right now they are a negative number, however.
There are also theories that the banks are hoarding cash and the money supply figures are no longer valid. The money is flowing to Europe and not into the US economy.
Well, we can look into this, but it does not seem to be borne out by anything we have looked at in more than one dimension yet. We have an open mind.
But we're short on economic creationism and long on hard data and analysis in our book.
"When you speak these things, they will not listen. When you call to them, they will not answer. 'This is the nation that would not listen to the Lord their God. Truth has perished among them. Raise up a dirge on the barren heights, for the Lord has rejected and abandoned them under His wrath. For the Judeans have done what is contemptible in My sight.' This is the Lord’s declaration. 'They have set up detestable things in the house that is called by My name — and defiled it.'" Jeremiah 7:27-30
