We Trust In God, Everyone Else Shows the Data
We like to check the data. The reason should be obvious, but if not, its because often people deal with the complexities of life by using assumptions, which are a kind of shorthand way of breaking reality down into manageable chunks. Everyone does it. You have to. But every once in a while its useful to check those assumptions you make, and that other people are making, to see if they are still valid, especially if they involve things that are important. Does your wife still love you? Is there a bus coming down the road you are crossing? Do you really still look as hot as you did last year? Are you financially solvent? Those sorts of things.
2007 Returns of Some Major Stock Indices
Let's compare the 2007 year-to-date performance of some of the major stock indices. As always, if you click on the chart you will see a larger, much easier to read version.
Its a little suprising that the Russell 2000 is still not quite positive for the year, not including dividends or subtracting fees and commissions. There was quite a bit more divergence in the gains of the major stock indices. An index after all is just a grouping of things for measurement purposes. The Russell is the broadest, most inclusive of the indexes we normally watch.It looks like tech was the champ of the broad stock sectors this year, if for no other reason that they are NOT financial and NOT housing. The Wall Street storyboard is that tech is invulnerable to the vagaries of housing and financial bubbles, and actually benefits from the weakened US dollar because the we are the champions, the kings of tech, and are selling it to the rest of the world, although very little of it is actually made here anymore, and what we do invent is copied and pirated shamelessly. Its a revenue concept thing perhaps, moreso than real hard cash, like page views and web searches and collateralized debt obligations.
Let's Get Physical
Let's take a look at a different type of investment. How about something that is supposed to be impervious to inflation, a barbarous relic, the bane of central banksters and financial voodoo? Since the generally transitory, subjective, and vaporous nature of financially engineered products is in the headlines it might not be a bad idea to throw in something with a long track record as a hardened test of monetary value into the mix.Holy goldaroney, Batman! That is one surprisingly fine performance for gold this year. Even we did not think that it has been this good. The assumption has been, at least lately, that gold's day will come soon, especially when the Central Banks get finished monkeying with it. Well, its been a much better return this year than most would think offhand. We're in that group, and we watch it! See how easy it is to fall prey to your own assumptions, especially when you think you have been watching something for a long time.
The Usual Investment Suspects
Let's widen the data net a little more, and see how different things compare. We apologize for the lack of variation in colors on this chart, but we had to tinker with the charting tool a little to get so many items on a single snapshot.
Well, there you have it. Some real information about how various investments performed during 2007. We new the US dollar was doing badly. We did not know that gold had done so well, and had outperformed most of the other major alternative so handily (don't forget about those dividends guys. Gold does not pay any, just like a high performing tech stock).
Let's have one more look at a sector that we have admittedly been cool towards for the latter half of this year, because of the general reluctance we have had toward equities.
Data Mining
Well, as someone who has not owned miners for the latter part of the year, we're just a little
disappointed that we overlooked such a hot performing sector. Its been a wild ride, and keep in mind that with high returns comes higher beta (variability of return aka risk, and lately that includes return of capital). Remember this is the HUI gold bugs index, and if you have been playing the junior miners heavily you might have ground your teeth to a fine white powder trying to ride those bucking beta broncos. Our personal preference is to find a few well financed miners that have a shot at paying dividends for a long time if the dollar really tanks and stocks gets smacked down. Bennie and Hank and crew are working overtime to make sure this happens, make no mistake about it. They are just trying to push the date of reckoning into the future. We admit to a bias that says the dollar will inflate significantly further, and then at some point deflate. Its just that we think the deflation will be when they knock a couple zeros off buckaroo. It might not happen that way. We'll stay flexible.
When people put forward ideas that might be important to you, ask for the data. People are often afraid to ask, because they don't want to look foolish. Some people like to put forward their ideas with great ceremony and pomp, and browbeat and belittle anyone who disagrees with them. They often speak with great confidence bordering on arrogance. We'll let you in on a little secret. What we have learned over the years is that if someone can't explain their ideas to you, it just might be that they do not understand the idea themselves. Don't get us wrong. There are some very fundamental beginner questions that people must and should as. Its just that they aren't necessarily best directed to the advanced class. But that doesn't mean you shouldn't ask. Just try to ask the right person in the right places in the right way.
Questions can be annoying. But we find that often they provide the kind of impedance that causes us to revisit them and test our assumptions, to try to explain things over again to ourselves. If you put in an honest effort, it makes our assumptions and ideas stronger, more reliable. Some people might even publish their ideas so that they can be tested in an environment of peer review. Just putting ideas down on paper forces one to really thing them through. You might even decide to put them into charts and a blog, to force your own performance to a higher standard. Interesting concept.
